In Defense Of Peter Green's
Original Fleetwood Mac
Friday, June 18, 2010
In my opinion, the reasons why Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac were indisputably the best of the British blues bands of their era boil down to five basic factors:
1) First and foremost obviously is the guitar mastery of the band's leader, Peter Green. While Eric Clapton --- who Green replaced in John Mayall's Bluesbreakers --- played with flair and intelligence, to my ear, it was Peter Green who demonstrated a more inherent understanding of blues. Green's sparse and soulful approach paid tribute to his mentors while simultaneously showcasing his own unique voice on the guitar. Although Clapton walked away with the glory, I believe it was Green who was more deserving of the British blues guitar crown. Plus he possessed a great blues voice. Gruff, gritty, and authentic.
2) The three guitar line-up. Jeremy Spencer was a fine slide guitarist, frequently added some tasty piano work, and was not too shabby of a vocalist either. To his credit, he was also an Elmore James devotee. But his contributions within Fleetwood Mac have otherwise always been somewhat baffling to me. Not to discredit him, but apparently Green felt that way too. Musically Spencer's interests centered on two things and only two things --- Elmore James and rock n' roll satire --- imitations of American 'Top 40' DJ's, do-wop parodies, acned teenage love ballads, and Buddy Holly covers. Green was in need of a harmonic foil who could hold his own against him. Despite Spencer's prowess on slide, an additional ingredient was needed, thus Danny Kirwan was drafted into the band. The resulting interplay between the three guitarists, Green, Kirwan and Spencer flowed as fluid as water running from the tap, the hot and cold perfectly blended at just the right temperature. No showboating, no smoking duels, no bullshit. Just delicate and responsive interaction. Each was quite capable in his own right, and they frequently shared the lead responsibilities depending on the needs of the song. A nice touch. The payoff was that it could sound like you were listening to three different blues bands sharing the same rhythm section. And as a threesome, they fed ideas to one another and bounced them around, fueling the songs to greater heights. P.S. --- Kirwan had an pleasing singing voice as well.
3) Speaking of the rhythm section, this leads us to the group's namesake, Mick Fleetwood and John McVie. While McVie may not have been the flashiest bass player around, he did lay down a simplistic, but solidly grounded and fat bottom. Fleetwood on the other hand was more than a simple timekeeper, although he could never be called a drummer's drummer. He did however play with unmatched authority and during those years had an extremely satisfying drum sound --- loud, booming and rock solid. The two man team did just what a great rhythm section should do --- supply an unbroken and dependable foundation for the soloists to ride on.
4) The material. Green and Kirwan were the band's principle songwriters, each with their own sensibility yet possessing an empathy for the style of their partner. As each ones writing skills matured to incorporate a touch of rock within their earlier and stricter 'nothing but the blues' approach, they collectively and individually penned several period classics, 'Albatross,' 'One Sunny Day,' 'Black Magic Woman,' 'The Green Manalishi,' 'Coming Your Way,' and 'Oh Well, Pts.1&2.' Additionally, the band's choice of covers was informed, broad based and often refreshing. Most welcoming however was that the Mac never succumbed to the dreaded 'boogie,' the embarrassing disgrace of far too many others. Detroit's 'Grande Ballroom' was especially a hotbed for that particular form of masturbation. It was bad enough when some knucklehead in the audience would shout, "Play the blooze!" because that meant that the guitarist on stage would then devote the next 20 minutes convincing us all of his manhood by shredding on what was supposed to be perceived as the most glorious and heartfelt solo ever played, a solo that 368 long and tedious bars later only seemed to scream, "Stop me, please! I can't help myself!" And in the end, the only thing that we, the hapless audience were persuaded of, was that he was simply a very large douchbag. But when I'd hear the call of "Let's boogie!" emanating from the house sound system, it was always an instant buzz killer. I had no choice but to head straight for the door. And don't even get me started on prog rock.
There's an instance of this unfortunate predilection included within Volume Three in the form of 'The Madge Sessions, Pt.1.' Wisely, the band saw fit to serve this up severely truncated on 'Then Play On,' but I've included it wholesale. Stupid of me. Stupid, stupid, stupid. I shouldn't have. Damn, I'm sorry I did. It's wanking, pure and simple, and just after I got done saying that the Mac could never stand accused. I guess it just goes to show that everything I say isn't gospel truth, and it serves as a reminder of just how mind-numbing that kind of 'let's jam on this' crap can actually be, even in the hands of Green, Kirwan, and Spencer. After one hour, forty minutes and the obligatory 'big finish,' Mick Fleetwood, apparently pissed off because he didn't get a solo, starts it all back up again to lukewarm response from his band mates who had blown their wads much earlier and were just too washed out. I shouldn't have included it, dammit.
5) The sound of their recordings. Here in America, Fleetwood Mac records were released on a high profile pop label (Reprise). In their homeland, the original Fleetwood Mac were part of the Blue Horizon stable of artists, a company that specialized in blues exclusively. And like most blues labels, the recordings they made were largely no-frill affairs, simple 'live in the studio' performances captured on two track tape. The sound quality could frequently be erratic, varying even from track to track. The Mac's records were no different. But in fact, it's that very characteristic that often made their discs so much more compelling. Forgoing superior hi-fidelity led to an authenticity that others who utilized upgraded technology sorely lacked, and it subsequently made Fleetwood Mac sound as gritty as a South-side Chicago bar band. Obviously that's what the band strived for and in doing so (combined with all of the above factors) made them in my estimation, the premiere British blues band of the 1960s.
So that's my defense, and I'm sticking to it. If you don't already concur with my closing argument, hopefully you'll be sufficiently swayed after listening to 'Peter Green's Original Fleetwood Mac, Volumes 1,2, & 3.'
One final note. Fleetwood Mac as an entity, both with and without Peter Green has carried more than it's share of hard luck. I've mentioned Green's battle with mental illness. Danny Kirwan too ended up living on the streets, a mere shadow of his former glory as a long time and integral member of Fleetwood Mac. Today he's invisible and forgotten. Just another sad and unfortunate old man you might never even notice as you walk down the street. The already weird Jeremy Spencer got hijacked by The Children of God while on tour with the band here in the United States. It was one of those situations where he stepped out for a pack of cigarettes and just never came back. Meanwhile, John McVie's poison of choice was apparently whiskey and rye. Today however he's a millionaire several times over. That may or may not make him a happy man, but it sure can buy a lot of alcohol. Surprisingly, drummer Mick Fleetwood seems to be the only one from the original line-up who escaped relatively unscathed, and perhaps that's because he had a drum kit to bash around.
Peter Green looking hairy, but sharp in a 1970 rock star kinda way
The Best Of Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac, Vol.3
1) My Baby's Sweeter
2) Intro/Lazy Poker Blues
3) Rollin' Man
4) Before The Beginning
5) Coming Your Way (Early Version)
6) My Baby's Good To Me
7) First Train Home
8) If You'll Be My Baby
9) Need Your Love Tonight
10) The Madge Sessions, Pt.1
11) Mean Old Fireman
12) Love That Woman
13) Like It This Way
14) Fast Talking Woman Blues
15) Underway (Full Length Version)
Source material for 'The Best Of Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac, Vols.1,2 & 3' come from the following:
Fleetwood Mac (1968)/Mr. Wonderful (1968)/English Rose (1968)
Then Play On (1969)/The Pious Bird Of Good Omen (1969)
The Original Fleetwood Mac (1971)
The Vaudeville Years (1999)/Show-Biz Blues (2001)
Jumping At Shadows (2002)/The Best Of Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac (2002)